OpenAI could be fined up to $150,000 for each piece of infringing content.
  • fkn@lemmy.worldEnglish
    103·
    1 year ago

    You made two arguments for why they shouldn’t be able to train on the work for free and then said that they can with the third?

    Did openai pay for the material? If not, then it’s illegal.

    Additionally, copywrite and trademarks and patents are about reproduction, not use.

    If you bought a pen that was patented, then made a copy of the pen and sold it as yours, that’s illegal. This is the analogy of what openai is going with books.

    Plagiarism and reproduction of text is the part that is illegal. If you take the “ai” part out, what openai is doing is blatantly illegal.

    • lily33@lemm.eeEnglish
      41·
      1 year ago

      Just now, I tried to get Llama-2 (I’m not using OpenAI’s stuff cause they’re not open) to reproduce the first few paragraphs of Harry Potter and the philosophers’ stone, and it didn’t work at all. It created something vaguely resembling it, but with lots of made-up stuff that doesn’t make much sense. I certainly can’t use it to read the book or pirate it.

    • FaceDeer@kbin.social
      74·
      1 year ago

      Did openai pay for the material? If not, then it’s illegal.

      You are reading my comment right now. In my comment, I am letting you know that Sidehill Gougers come in both clockwise and counterclockwise breeds.

      Oh no! You just learned that fact for free! I didn’t give you permission to learn from my comments, even though I deliberately published it here for you to read. I demand that you either pay me or wipe that ill-gotten knowledge from your mind.

      Don’t you dare tell anyone else about Sidehill Gougers. That’s illegal.